Genre: Young Adult Fiction, Contemporary
Published: October 17, 2017 by: Crown Books for Young Readers
Pages: 224
Rating: 5/5 stars
CW: racism against Black people on both the macro and micro level, murder, police brutality, gun violence
Justyce McAllister is a bright teen set on going to an Ivy League university. But his confidence is shattered when a white police officer puts him in handcuffs for no reason. After receiving targeting from his classmates due to the incident, Justyce begins writing letters to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., hoping to find some answers to the world he is living in. Justyce's life is once more turned over when he is targeted by another white cop, this time while driving with his friend Manny. Justyce is trying to recover from one tragedy after another, and all the media cares about is labelling him and other Black teens as the villains. He begins to lose hope, but seeks comfort in the civil rights activists who came before him.
I read this book all in one sitting. It is not for someone looking for a light read. It is heartbreaking, disturbing, and unfortunately so incredibly real. I completely understand, especially nowadays, if people would rather seek stories featuring Black teens who are happy, without tragedy. I need that too. But, I do think this book was an emotional experience that was important, as a non-Black person, for me to go through.
Justyce was an incredible character. He is so well-rounded, and Nic Stone writes teen characters very well. I appreciated how Justyce went through a range of emotions throughout the novel. He is not put in this position where he needs to be the hero, he needs to have it all together and never break down. Justyce does lose hope. He is recovering from some serious trauma. Stone represents him as an average teen who has had immense pressure put on him. I appreciated that Justyce is well-developed throughout the novel.
I thought the format of this novel was super unique. The incorporation of the letters to Dr. Martin Luther King was a great idea on Stone's part, because it gives us a look into Justyce's mind as opposed to just the story that is going on around him. The letters are so personal and real, it almost seems like Justyce is a real person. I thought that displaying this book as someone from the modern world, looking back to someone from the past, was a really great way to display topics such as racism and police brutality. Because we do see everyday how history repeats itself. Stone is able to represent this in a poignant but also powerful way.
I think it is my duty as a non-Black person to read the stories of Black people, both the good but also the bad. This book not only shows the racism that Black people endure on the macro level, but also the microaggressions that occur in Justyce's own school community. We know these stories are disturbing, and we usually avoid talking about them. But, when we avoid talking about anti-Black racism because we fear we're getting too "political" then we are entering a harmful idea that human rights are somehow political, which they are certainly not. Talk about anti-Black racism. Support Black authors. And don't expect Black people to have it all together to educate you. Do the work yourself. Black Lives Matter.
Emily @ Paperback Princess
I've heard a lot of amazing things about Nic Stone's writing and definitely need to pick something up soon. I agree that as being someone from a different racial culture, it's so important to be reading stories, both good and bad, to be able to be good allies for marginalized communities. Especially in light of all that's happening, supporting and uplifting the stories and voices of others is incredibly important.
ReplyDeleteriv @ small stained pages
Well said, Riv! I would totally recommend Nic Stone's writing.
DeleteI really loved this book too, and I'm eager to read the sequel!
ReplyDeleteNicole @ Feed Your Fiction Addiction
I definitely can't wait to read the sequel!
Delete"But, when we avoid talking about anti-Black racism because we fear we're getting too "political" then we are entering a harmful idea that human rights are somehow political, which they are certainly not."
ReplyDelete👍
The format sounds so unique, too!
It was a very unique format for a novel. Highly recommend!
DeleteOne eye-opening thing (of several, obv.,) to me with this book was the reasons Justyce's mother had for him not dating a White girl weren't about disliking White girls, or thinking Black girls were better, or whatever, but a genuine worry about what other White people would think when they saw them together, and what that might mean to his physical safety. I'd not thought about that before.
ReplyDeleteAnd I think that's just one of the reasons it's important to listen to Black people, read books by Black creators, etc. - seeing the things that we've never had to think about.
That's a great point, Cee! This book explored many issues of anti-Black racism, including that of inter-racial relationships which I thought was eye-opening as well. We need to learn about every aspect of anti-Black racism, and it comes from reading books such as this.
DeleteSounds like a tough read but a necessary one in many ways- you're right, we need to read about the black experience if we're not black, it's not the same as going through racism ourselves but at least it gives us a perspective so we know more. I'm glad this was such a fulfilling read for you- sounds great even though it was heartbreaking at times.
ReplyDeleteThanks for reading, Greg! Yes, even though we will never be able to experience being black, the least we can do is learn.
DeleteI loooooved every page of this book. I had forgotten i had read it. Thank you so much for refreshing my memories. It was so hard tk read it, I can remember I cried a lot. I will deffinitely re-read. Have a good day
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by! I'm glad I could refresh your memories a bit. It was an awesome book, and while it was a very hard read, I can see myself re-reading it.
Delete